Thursday, June 5, 2014

Student Loan's Impact on Housing; FHA's Recent Numbers



 

Words are great things. (Sometimes I wish my kids would use them.) Let's take the poor financial news headline writer who hears about a few layoffs at some bank or lender. The writer pretty much has at their disposal cuts, slashes, slices, reduces, decreases, cuts back, declines, drops, falls, chops, prunes, removes, expurgates, hacks, incises, severs, or curtails, to name a few. Now let's take the statistician who relies on numbers to tell their story, but who can be accused equally of exaggeration. And so it is important to keep these things in mind when you read, "Chrisman LLC cat workforce slashed by 50 Percent". It might merely mean that I told Gusto that her services were no longer needed, leaving me with Myrtle. Yes, the numbers went from two felines to one, but the headline is a little sensationalized. (And yes, Gusto is a girl - it is important to live life with gusto, right?) And if house price appreciation last year was 10%, and this year someone expects house prices to "only" be up 6%, one headline could be, "House Price Appreciation Rate Expected to Plummet 40%." Be careful out there folks!


 The Mutual Mortgage Insurance Fund is a fund that insures mortgages made by the Federal Housing Administration on single-family homes; the fund must make quarterly reports to Congress. These reports are a fulfillment of the requirement under section 2118 of the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008 that HUD report to the Congress on a quarterly basis respecting mortgages that are an obligation of the Mutual Mortgage Insurance Fund. HUD uses this report to provide public information on new endorsement activity, delinquency, claim and prepayment rate trends, and financial information on core insurance operations. Highlights from Q1'14 (found here) include some not-so-surprising details regarding originations over the first three months of the new year. The forward-loan endorsement count was 208,488 with a dollar volume of $35.8B (which represents a 28% decrease in dollar volume from the previous quarter), prepayment activity was 26% above actuarial predictions (attributable to low interest rates), and the year-to-date net loss rate on claim activity (53%) remained below actuarial projections of 56%. 

With rising home prices, and stagnant wages over the last few years, more and more middle class buyers are being pushed out of the market. No more so, than in high cost of living areas such as Los Angeles, or New York City. In the same vein, I was recently asked by someone NOT in banking (yes, they're out there) "what's all this talk about the burden of student loans? It's simple, you take out a loan for anything, and then you pay it off, right?" Yes, I agree; however the conversation is a little more complex, as we're not talking about financing a Honda Accord. Some believe there is a systemic issue with student debt, that the ever-increasing cost of financing a college education, disproportionately carries over into young adulthood; that this debt, prohibits a vast majority of young adults from buying that 'starter home'. This is turn, impacts housing consumption levels, if you believe economists (which you shouldn't). It's a "35,000 foot" conversation, and if you're reading this while staring at a stack of loan files yet to be processed or underwritten, it's of little help to you. If that's the case, then click on this video of Tim Rood, co-founder of the Collingwood Group, who was recently on Fox Business News discussing this exact topic.

 Informative Research (a mortgage information services provider) announced that it has successfully completed the Experian Independent Third Party Assessment (EI3PA) certification. These technical and operational assessments are designed to help protect consumer information and enhance consumer compliance. "The EI3PA certification is an annual assessment of an Experian reseller`s ability to protect the information they receive from Experian.  EI3PA requires companies to go beyond the already stringent PCI DSS 2.0 standards and prove more areas of their infrastructure are secure for full compliance. This entails an extensive strenuous evaluation of information security by a 3rd Party Quality Security Assessor (QSA), based on requirements provided by Experian. These requirements have been adapted from PCI-DSS 2.0 standards." I am so not an IT guy, but I am sure this makes sense to someone out there...

I'm convinced Wells Fargo's Economics Group doesn't sleep. In April's Housing Data Wrap Up the group writes, "There has been a steady tide of negative housing reports over the past few months that have raised doubts about the housing recovery.  Sales of new and existing homes have weakened, mortgage applications have fallen, and the homeownership rate has plunged to its lowest level in 20 years.  New home construction has also slowed. Single-family housing starts through the first three months of this year are running 1.6 percent below their year-ago pace, and starts of multi-family units are down 3.8 percent." But all is not lost just yet, as the report is some-what optimistic; seeing conditions improving this year, even after a disappointing Q1, with expectations for new home sales to rise 14.2% to 490,000 homes in 2014 and a 20.4% rise to 590,000 homes in 2015. While I still enjoy reading the groups reports online, our cat Myrtle doesn't have the time, or the patience, to sit still with so many song-birds at the feeder this time of year, and prefers to listen to their podcast instead.

Rates: up a little, down a little. Tomorrow that may change with the unemployment data, but we've been in a decent rate environment for quite some time. (By the way, Nonfarm payrolls are expected at +218k versus +288k previously, with the unemployment rate up one-tenth to 6.4%.) Yesterday's ADP number, always of dubious predictive ability for the "real" number, disappointed many, but the Fed's Beige Book, which certainly trumps ADP, saw further improvement in the economy from the April report. In fact, all twelve Federal Reserve Districts reported that economic activity expanded. 

But probably of more important to anyone reading these words is The Beige Book's report on real estate. To the surprise of few, residential real estate activity was mixed since the last report, "with a lack of inventory at times cited as a constraining factor." Five districts reported sales were higher and four districts reported softer; homebuilders also gave mixed reports on new home sales and construction, while residential real estate lending was mixed as well. 

For numeros, Wednesday agency MBS prices were pretty much unchanged and the 10-yr closed at a yield of 2.61%. Today we've had the weekly Initial Jobless Claims (312k, +8k from a revised 304k). Later we'll have some information on prepayment speeds, and the Treasury telling us how much it is going to auction next week in the way of 3, 10, and 30 year securities. After the Jobless Claims numbers rates and MBS prices are basically unchanged from Wednesday's closing levels.

 

Rate Market Report:



As expected, the ECB cut its base lending rate to a record low 0.15% and lowered its deposit rate to minus 0.1% from zero,

also as expected. Draghi said the ECB will introduce new, “targeted” offerings of liquidity to banks to encourage them to lend money to the real economy. Officials will also start work on purchases of asset-backed securities, he said. The ECB will extend its current offerings of unlimited cash to banks and will suspend the sterilization of its bond purchases at the start of the euro crisis in a bid to boost liquidity in money markets, Draghi said. The ECB is now the first central bank to charge a fee on deposits at the bank. In order to support bank lending to households and non-financial corporations, excluding loans to households for house purchase, the ECB will be conducting a series of targeted longer-term refinancing operations (TLTROs). From March 2015 to June 2016, all counterparties will be able to borrow, quarterly, up to three times the amount of their net lending to the euro area non-financial private sector, excluding loans to households for house purchase, over a specific period in excess of a specified benchmark. Net lending will be measured in terms of new loans minus redemptions. Loan sales, securitizations and write-downs do not affect the net lending measure. The interest rate on the TLTROs will be fixed over the life of each operation, at the rate on the Euro system’s main refinancing operations (MROs) prevailing at the time of take-up, plus a fixed spread of 10 basis points. Starting 24 months after each TLTRO, counterparties will have the option to make repayments. A number of provisions will aim to ensure that the funds support the real economy. Those counterparties that have not fulfilled certain conditions regarding the volume of their net lending to the real economy will be required to pay back borrowings in September 2016. Sounds confusing, the bottom line though is more emphasis on lending to juice the economies in the EU.

Weekly jobless claims were about what was expected, +8K to 312K. The 4 week average declined 2500 to 310,250. No reaction to the report ahead of tomorrow’s May employment report and most focus this morning on the ECB’s actions to stimulate its economy and attempt drive an increase in inflation that at the moment is so low (0.5%) that fears of deflation have ignited great fears at the central bank.

At 9:30 the DJIA opened +36, NASDAQ +10, S&P +3; 10 yr 2.61% +1 bp and 30 yr MBS price +2 bp from yesterday’s close.

Now that the ECB has essentially done what markets had expected, it is on to tomorrow’s employment report. There hasn’t been a lot of reaction to the ECB after the initial volatility at about 8:30; markets had already discounted it over the last week. Tomorrow’s employment report is hard to discount prior to actually seeing the data as generally the report presents surprises. The current ‘consensus’ is NFP jobs up 213K, private jobs +215K and the unemployment rate at 6.4% from 6.3% in April.

The technicals have broken down with the recent selling; the 10 now above its 20 and 40 day averages and the momentum oscillators are now in bearish territory. We will have to wait until tomorrow to decide where rates are headed; a weaker than expected report will help stabilize the markets. Ukraine/Russia is still a factor but unless a country wide civil war breaks out markets are not likely to be directly affected. 
http://globalhomefinance.blogspot.com

No comments:

Post a Comment